Buy Existing Paper - Euthyphro’s First Definition of Holiness

Description

Euthyphro’s First Definition of Holiness

When asked by Socrates, Euthyphro first defines holiness as the prosecution of religious offenders or wrongdoers who commit sacrilegious robbery, murder or sins. Failure to prosecute religious offenders would be contemplated as unholy.

This definition of holiness is justified by the fact that Euthyphro took it upon himself to prosecute his own father on charges of impiety for the unintentional act of killing a murderous hired hand. Since Euthyphro is willing to prosecute his own father, Socrates flatters him as one who is quite knowledgeable in matters regarding holiness.

In his objection of this definition, Socrates states that this definition is unsatisfactory since it is just an example of holiness or a holy action and not a general definition of the holiness, that is, a definition that determines what makes all holy actions holy.

Euthyphro’s First Definition of Holiness

When asked by Socrates, Euthyphro first defines holiness as the prosecution of religious offenders or wrongdoers who commit sacrilegious robbery, murder or sins. Failure to prosecute religious offenders would be contemplated as unholy.

This definition of holiness is justified by the fact that Euthyphro took it upon himself to prosecute his own father on charges of impiety for the unintentional act of killing a murderous hired hand. Since Euthyphro is willing to prosecute his own father, Socrates flatters him as one who is quite knowledgeable in matters regarding holiness.

In his objection of this definition, Socrates states that this definition is unsatisfactory since it is just an example of holiness or a holy action and not a general definition of the holiness, that is, a definition that determines what makes all holy actions holy.

Euthyphro’s First Definition of Holiness

When asked by Socrates, Euthyphro first defines holiness as the prosecution of religious offenders or wrongdoers who commit sacrilegious robbery, murder or sins. Failure to prosecute religious offenders would be contemplated as unholy.

This definition of holiness is justified by the fact that Euthyphro took it upon himself to prosecute his own father on charges of impiety for the unintentional act of killing a murderous hired hand. Since Euthyphro is willing to prosecute his own father, Socrates flatters him as one who is quite knowledgeable in matters regarding holiness.

In his objection of this definition, Socrates states that this definition is unsatisfactory since it is just an example of holiness or a holy action and not a general definition of the holiness, that is, a definition that determines what makes all holy actions holy.